American heritage pencil maker Musgrave introduced a very interesting product in 2019: The Tennessee Red pencil. The pencil’s notable feature is the use of Eastern Red Cedar (Juniperus virginiana), the original American pencil wood. The pencil is very fragrant and visually interesting – each pencil is different, and many contain both cedar sapwood (pale colour) and cedar heartwood (dark colour).
The pencils are reminiscent of the old Musgrave HB in presentation, though the wood and lead are different. I found the Tennessee Red challenging to sharpen in a handheld sharpener like the M+R Pollux, with the lead snapping. Fortunately it is easily handled with the standard Grenade or a desktop sharpener. Still, the wood seems just a bit too tough for a pencil. I suspect this isn’t the fault of the timber – it is more that the slats just haven’t received the conditioning treatments to which we’ve become accustomed.
The lead is dark and rapidly crumbles. It certainly isn’t the quality of the old HB. It is perfectly usable, and I find this lead preferable to the anemic grainy lead of many no name pencils.
It isn’t a good pencil. Yet, it is unusual and compelling in multiple ways. I hope it will continue, perhaps with gradual improvements. In an unusually transparent act, the manufacturer has noted that the pencil has issues.
There are product reviews at Weekly Pencil and Pencil Revolution.
The Tennessee Red has a second aspect – it appears to be the subject of a small advertising campaign being conducted on Musgrave’s website and social media. The pencil has some nice new packaging including a cedar box option, and they are selling paraphernalia such as T-shirts.
Congratulations, Musgrave! It is really nice to see a new pencil being promoted.
To me, the most interesting aspect of this pencil is Musgrave’s disruption of the pencil supply chain. They have found a way to circumvent the cedar slat supplier CalCedar. Did you read the pencil’s imprint? “Genuine Eastern Red Cedar”. Wow. That is to me a very clear shot across the bow directed at CalCedar’s “Genuine Incense Cedar”. (They aren’t the first to rework this phrasing to make a point.) This pencil is also a statement about the pencil supply chain.
So how were these slats made? Perhaps pioneer fellow Tennessee manufacturer Wagner Pencil, who process American timber into pencil slats, gave assistance. Or perhaps Musgrave engaged with a wood processor not part of the pencil industry to create these slats. In any case, it is very interesting.
Private companies of course don’t reveal their internal business, but in some countries (including the US), there are public customs records that show import activity. Records from Import Genius show that in the last two years, Musgrave’s imports include:
|Basswood Slats||Qingdao Greatwall (China)|
|Erasers||Kunshan Greenwill (China)|
|Poplar Slats||Qingdao Greatwall (China)|
|Erasers and Ferrules||Shai Tai Shing (Vietnam)|
|Slats||Lishui Liancheng Pencil Manufacturing (China)|
|Slats||Pt. Gemilang Jaya Makmur Pratama (Singapore)|
From another perspective, Import Genius says that Musgrave’s top international suppliers (ranked by number of containers imported) are:
1. Tianjin Custom Wood Processing Co. (CalCedar’s Chinese production)
2. Great Wall Industrial Qingdao
3. Lishui Liancheng Pencil Manufacturing
4. Kunshan Greenwill Co.
Very clearly, this small town Tennessee company is highly engaged in the international economy. As the company notes, “… today Musgrave is able to work with a handful of different varieties of wood from all over the world.” Managing this complex supply chain must be almost as challenging as manufacturing the pencils.
Investing in and testing a historically proven local wood source is just savvy business sense. It benefits the environment and eliminates multiple containers from having to be shipped across the Pacific. For many reasons, local initiatives like this pencil from Musgrave should be supported!
9 Replies to “Musgrave and the pencil supply chain”
Thank you for presenting this special pencil and for the exciting background details!
I would love to support Musgrave but unfortunately the company does not ship to Germany. I will keep looking for a distributor.
You are most welcome. I think the pencil’s background is an interesting subject.
I hope Musgrave will expand sales internationally. I can’t imagine why they wouldn’t want the business. Or perhaps this is an opportunity for a retailer in Europe to pick up the Musgrave line?
I believe that the Tennessee Reds are available from Nero’s Notes in the UK.
Adam, thanks for the tip!
I’m sorry, I’m confused. Is the company just sourcing all it’s wood from China? That’s what I’m gleaning from this article. Also, what’s the deal with CalCedar? Why would circumventing them be good? If this pencil isn’t good then why support a company that makes a subpar product? Can someone elaborate?
Jason, thank you, I believe you are a long time reader of this blog.
The article cites Musgrave using American, Vietnamese and Singaporean slat suppliers, and doesn’t claim completeness of this list. The central focus of the article is that Musgrave is using a new American supplier – so Musgrave has definitely not been solely using a Chinese wood supply.
Avoiding a single supplier is just good business sense. And finding a local supplier is additionally beneficial for the environment. Finding a way to make more of a pencil locally is a breakthrough.
I call the pencil “okay” in the context of fifteen years of pencil reviews here and in comparison to the best Musgrave products. For perspective, I also linked to two reviews that are much more favourable. I have been using the Red as a writing pencil, and it requires more sharpening (and has a less pleasant sharpening experience) than I’d like. The mark is pleasing, but there seems to be some crumbling as the line is created. I think there is a chance of improving the product over time.
If you like pencils, you may want to support Musgrave and the other small pencil companies because they are few in number, and offer a different type of product than their global competitors.
I’ve gone through a number of Tennessee Reds since they began selling them in 2019 and I’ve yet to see any crumbling of the core. Though I agree that they sharpen much better in a crank sharpener, and have gotten wonderful points with my Dahle 133, Carl Angel-5 Royal, and El Casco.
Josh, thanks for your comment!